Woman sues ex-fiance, wants her Chevy pickup back

Lawsuit: Man “unjustifiably terminated the engagement” with woman but kept 2012 Chevrolet Colorado.
TNS Regional News
Jun 14, 2013


A Dayton woman is suing her former fiance because she says he used her to get financing for a Chevy pickup truck he couldn’t obtain because of bad credit.

After the engagement ended, Erin Maggard claims the payments came due on the pickup and the credit union came after her instead of Centerville’s Richard Thomas III.

The civil lawsuit filed in Montgomery County Common Pleas Court indicates the couple were engaged in May 2012 when Thomas allegedly induced Maggard into incurring a loan for more than $24,000 for a 2012 Chevrolet Colorado.

Maggard said Thomas couldn’t get financing on his own because of low credit scores, but that he said he would make payments. By Oct. 19, 2012, Thomas “unjustifiably terminated the engagement” with Maggard but kept the Colorado.

The suit alleges Thomas didn’t make payments and Maggard was called by the credit union who issued the loan regarding lack of payment. Maggard said she asked for the vehicle to be issued in her name only, and, despite promises by Thomas to do so, he did not turn over the paperwork and avoided her.

The pickup was repossessed, causing Thomas to make payments to regain possession of the Colorado. Maggard alleges the vehicle incurred collision damage while in Thomas’ possession and that the damage remains because insurance was not maintained.

The suit said Thomas has been “unjustly enriched” by obtaining the title without incurring any financial obligation and that has damaged Maggard, who wants the truck and paperwork to show she’s the owner

The other charge listed is fraud, with Maggard saying Thomas induced her into financing the loan on his behalf “knowing that he was not going to maintain or pursue a marital relationship.”

Maggard is seeking damages in excess of $25,000 and attorney fees. Thomas, who has no attorney of record listed in court records, hasn’t yet answered the suit.


By Mark Gokavi - Dayton Daily News, Ohio (MCT)

©2013 the Dayton Daily News (Dayton, Ohio)

Visit the Dayton Daily News (Dayton, Ohio) at www.daytondailynews.com

Distributed by MCT Information Services



a chevy is a good truck..

Karma Watcher

I have had similar issue. I wish this woman good luck. So many men do this kind of thing. Makes me sick. Losers.


You are right. Chevy is a great truck!


So the guy's a loser sucking off a woman. What's news about this???


When you co-sign for someone, the responsibility comes back on you when that person doesn't hold up their end of the deal. This is a bad judgement call, not a lawsuit. Get real lady.



Everyone is fam...

I bet her friends warned her and she didn't want to listen, and somehow they ended up the bad guys. I have an old friend who consistently dates jail birds and can't figure out why she keeps getting screwed over. Hopefully one day she figures out she doesn't need a man to survive and if anything, wises up and quits falling prey.

Really are you ...

If it looks like poo and smells like poo, it is probably poo. Stand clear and let someone else take care of it. She should have had better taste in the dating pool.


And why is this even on here...Take it to Judge Joe Brown.....Get with it!


I would have taken the truck back after the break up.


Eff-Oh-Are-Dee. FORD... won't buy a SHEVROLAY cuz I caint spell it